written by David Steffen
Hello! I am here to announce the original stories that were chosen from the general submission window that ran in July 2024.
First, some stats:
# of Stories Submitted: 1323
# Rejected (First Round): 1220
# Rejected (Final Round): 57
# Withdrawn: 15
# Disqualified: 2
# Rewrite Requests: 6
# Accepted: 23
Note that the overall numbers might include some authors twice in some circumstances. This can happen if an author withdraws before any of the first readers read it, they are allowed to submit another story in its place. Also, if a submission becomes a rewrite request, if the author submits the rewrite while the window is still open then the rewrite would become a second submission to the window. Or a combination of these could make several submissions for a single author.
The overall submission count is lower than the previous window by about a hundred, but there was still plenty of great stories to choose from, enough that we had to send rejection letters for many stories we would have been happy to publish.
This year we recruited a new first reader team because our first reader team carrying over from year to year had grown smaller over a couple years as some first readers got busy with other life things and couldn’t come back. The team with a bunch of new members worked their way through the queue with amazing speed while giving each story the same full opportunity as every other story–many hands make light work. This helped keep the window flowing as the editors never had to wait for a submission to have two votes on it (as you can tell by this announcement coming out almost 6 weeks earlier than last year’s announcement despite the window running about the same time of the year!). Our first readers are an amazing crew and we appreciate their immense help! Check out our staff page for a partial list of our first readers if you want to learn more about them!
If you have any comments or questions feel free to comment here or to send us a message through our contact form.
Changes Since the Last Window
We did have a few relevant changes to the submission system software since the last submission window.
In previous years, we did occasionally request rewrites from authors if we thought a story was almost an acceptance and we had something specific and concrete that we could request that (if the author was interested) could move it to become an acceptance. This was always handled outside of the submission system, where one of the editors would mark it as a Rejection but would edit the rejection letter to request chances and invite the author to send in changes. Changes in these cases were generally handled by having the author email one or more of the editors directly, and wasn’t handled by the submission system at all, which made it harder to keep track of, harder to collaborate on (need to forward it to other editors for them to see rather than being in a central location).
After the window last year, just before posting the summary, the submission system has been set up now so that a submission can be marked with the terminal status of Rewrite Request. When a Rewrite Request response is sent, it automatically also includes a special one-time resubmit link. The author can use this at any time. They can use it during the same window, which will bypass the usual one-submission-per-window limit. They can use it when there is no submission window. The link expires after a year (just for data cleanup purposes) but we can regenerate a link after that year on request. When a submission comes back into the system it will be treated somewhat differently, such as notifying both the Editor-In-Chief and the requesting editor. It will also bypass the usual requirement for two first readers to vote on it before it’s resolved, because it has already been seen by editors and was of interest enough to cause a Rewrite Request result. In addition, the submission system links to both the current text and the original text so the editors can compare what has changed if they like.
We also added the ability to handle solicitations to authors through the system. We occasionally solicited authors before, but it was always handled entirely out of the system which again made it harder to coordinate and keep track of it. This works very similarly to the Rewrite Request, producing a one-time link. The main difference is that a solicitation can be generated out of nowhere instead of requiring an existing submission record to start from.
And, since last year we added to the submission form an option for the author to enter Content Notes for the first reader team. We’d tried this in a previous year but had gotten some feedback on the way it was implemented that prompted us to pause the idea and come back to it later when we had time to take the feedback into account. Content Notes are never required but are appreciated! Our first reader team appreciates having a heads up on things like whether the story has the death of a pet, or spousal abuse, or things like that: that way a first reader can either brace themselves for it, or can choose to skip over it if they choose to and let another first reader who is more ready for that to handle it. When our first readers are often reading dozens of stories a week (sometimes even more!) that it can be very taxing to walk into stories with some topics without having a head’s up first and these content notes are very helpful. Authors, though not required to do this, seemed to use it very conscientiously, as stories that our first readers thought should have a warning usually had a relevant warning. So we appreciate authors participating in this when they are able!
The Lineup
The Witches Who Drowned
by R.J. Becks
On the Effects and Efficiency of Birdsong: A Meta-Analysis
by F.T. Berner
The Unfactory
by Derrick Boden
The Glorious Pursuit of Nominal
by Lisa Brideau
Irina, Unafraid
by Anna Clark
The Statue Hunt
by E. Carey Crowder
The Matador and the Labyrinth
by C.C. Finlay
Please Properly Cage Your Words
by Beth Goder
The Rat King Who Wasn’t
by Stephen Granade
In His Image
by R. Haven
The Interview
by Tim Hickson
Paths, Littlings, and Holy Things
by Somto Ihezue
The Year the Sheep God Shattered
by Marissa Lingen
Resurrection Scars
by Sheila Massie
Application For Continuance: vMeet Restroom Utility (RedemptionMod)
by Ethan Charles Reed
Will He Speak With Gentle Words?
by A.J. Rocca
Laser Eyes Ain’t Everything
by Effie Seiberg
(Skin)
by Chelsea Sutton
When Eve Chose Us
by Tia Tashiro
The Octopus Dreams of Personhood
by Hannah Yang
The Saint of Arms
by Mason Yeater
Skin as Warp, Blood as Weft
by Lilia Zhang
Our Lady of the Elevator
by Shiwei Zhou